Lieutenant 3
- 2023 Max Stong
- 2021 Michael Voeltner
- 2020 Taylor Bare
- 2019 Jay Droney
- 2017 Matthew Mudry
- 2014 Patrick Kraushaar
- 2012 Andrew Klink
- 2011 Cody Lockwood
- 2009 Gregory Tietmeyer
- 2007 Craig Temple
- 2006 Rancel Evans Jr.
- 2005 Craig Temple
- 2003 Mark Lloyd
- 2001 Craig Temple
- 1998 Mark Lloyd
- 1998 Brice Hickman
- 1997 Eddie Hammond
- 1996 Eddie Hammond
- 1996 Brice Hickman
- 1995 Brice Hickman
- 1995 Brian Mushrush
- 1994 Craig Temple
- 1994 Eric Huovinen Sr.
- 1993 Bobby Magee
- 1993 Eric Huovinen Sr.
- 1992 Craig Temple
- 1992 Garland Saville
- 1991 Clarke Droney
- 1991 Garland Saville
- 1990 Clarke Droney
- 1990 Craig Temple
- 1989 Clarke Droney
- 1987 Guy Rickards
